Document Type : Original Article

Author

Assistant professor of Economics, Shiraz University

Abstract

Extended abstract
1- INTRODUCTION
The Heritage Foundation has developed the Economic Freedom Index since 1995. Over the past 25 years, the global average score of this index has grown by 2.3, and many countries worldwide have joined the group of free countries on average. Many countries abundance of natural resources has become a curse due to their weak institutional structure. The high revenues from the sale of resources have led to rent-seeking, corrupt and repressive governments. Evidence shows that economic freedom in these countries is not in a good situation. In this regard, we test the following two hypotheses: First, Corruption undermines economic freedom. Second, in addition to directly impacting economic freedom. Corruption can also affect the impact of natural resource income on economic freedom so that the impact of natural income on economic freedom is different at any level of corruption. for this purpose, using the data of forty-nine selected countries with abundant resources during the period 2002-2017, the effect of corruption on the impact of natural income on the economic freedom of these countries has been studied.
2- THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK
Countries with natural resources create corruption and rent-seeking. One of the measures taken by the rentier government to solve problems in the manufacturing sector and protect investors is to keep bank interest rates low. Since this interest rate is usually lower than the market equilibrium rate, it creates an excess demand for loans, and the government is forced to either implement the credit quota or subsidize the production sector. The implementation of any of these policies is defined in the context of financial repression. Another feature of resource-rich countries is subsidies and price suppression. Suppression of prices is one of the factors reducing economic freedom through the component of monetary freedom. Monetary freedom is a measure of price stability combined with price control assessments. Both inflation and price control disrupt the market; price stability without economic interference (at the micro-level) is ideal for the free market. From the entrepreneur to the consumer, all economic factors need a stable and reliable currency to use as a means of exchange, a unit of counting and storing value. Without monetary freedom, it will not be easy to create long-term value for capital. Inflationary policies destroy the wealth of individuals in society and act as an invisible tax. In addition, distorting prices leads to inadequate resource allocation and increases business costs. Although no single monetary policy can be recommended for all countries, most monetary theories support low inflation and central bank independence. It is also accepted that price control disrupts market efficiency and leads to surplus or shortage. Therefore, natural income can hurt economic freedom.
3- METHODOLOGY
            The data used in the present study are the economic freedom index, natural resources revenue as a percentage of GDP, the index of corruption perception, and the index of political stability. Regarding the corruption perceptions index, it should be added that this index shows corruption in the public sector of one country compared to other countries and is ranked between 0 and 100. the higher the rank of a country, the less corruption there is in that country. Samti et al. (2006), Graeff and Mehlkop (2003), Jichi and Cabro (2019), and Alsarhan (2019) have also shown that economic freedom affects Corruption. Therefore, due to the possibility of endogenous problems in the model, the framework of the dynamic panel model is used. However, in some cases, the regression function may not be the same for the whole observation, and the regression can be divided into different parts based on a specific threshold value. In this regard, Hansen (1999) has proposed a threshold non-dynamic panel model. However, in this model, the endogenous bias between the dependent and independent variables is not considered. In order to consider endogeny, Caner and Hansen (2004) developed Hansen (1999) model by adding endogenous variables and exogenous threshold variables. Nevertheless, the model proposed by these researchers also cannot be used for dynamic panels. Finally, a model that can be used in a dynamic panel model is introduced by Kremer et al. (2013).
4- RESULTS & DISCUSSION
            The results of the study show that corruption hurts economic freedom. This result is consistent with the results of studies by Emerson (2006), Apergis et al. (2012), Yamarik and Redmon (2017) and Jichi, and Cabro (2019). In addition, the second hypothesis of the research is also confirmed; The results show that if the corruption perception index is less than 32, the income from the sale of natural resources hurts economic freedom. However, for countries with a corruption perception index above the threshold (countries with a lower level of Corruption), natural income cannot significantly affect economic freedom. countries with abundant resources have a very favorable ground for the formation of corruption and rent-seeking activities.
5- CONCLUSIONS & SUGGESTIONS
The present study results suggest that if a resource-rich country has Corruption above the threshold, natural income will be spent on repressive economic policies and reduce economic freedom. However, if the level of Corruption is controlled to some extent, the negative and positive effects of the abundance of resources on economic freedom will neutralize each other. In general, the effect of natural income on economic freedom will be insignificant. Overall, the results indicate that the improvement of the weak economic freedom of selected countries with abundant resources depends on the improvement of Corruption in these countries. However, many of these countries have a long way to reach the Corruption Perceptions Index threshold level. Thus, the policy recommendation for these countries is to strengthen the regulatory components, both on the activities of the government and those who have a key role in the resource management system, to provide the basis for accountability of these actors and thus, the formation of corruption restricted.

Keywords

References
Alsarhan. A.A. (2019). Determinants of Corruption in Middle East Countries: Evidence from Panel Data. International Journal of Economic Behavior and Organization. 7(4). 57-63.
Ali. A. & Crain. W. M. (2002). Institutional Distortions. Economic Freedom Growth. Cato Journal. 21. 415–26.
Amiri. H. Nowruzi, Amouqin. F. Pirdadeh Biranvand. M. & Sh. Alizadeh. (2018). Investigating Economic Freedom on Economic Growth with a Resistive Economy Approach. Economic Journal. 5,6. 30-5. (In Persian).
Apergis. N., O. Dincer. & J. E. Payne. )2012(. Live Free or Bribe: On the Causal Dynamics between Economic Freedom and Corruption in US States. European Journal of Political Economy. 28(2). 215–26.
Asongu. S. (2017). Does globalization promote good governance in Africa? an empirical study across 51 countries. World Affairs. 180(2).  105–141.
Bafandeh Iman Doost. S., M. Ghaemi Asl.  & B. Eliaspour. (2016). Assessing the Causality of Three Variables Between Economic Freedom. Financial Development and Economic Growth in Iran (Vol. 1973-2010). Theories of Financial Economics. 5. 106-75. (In Persian).
Beland L. Ph. & R. Tiagi. (2009). Economic Freedom and The Resource Curse. Working Paper. Fraser Institute.
Campbell. N. D. & T. Snyder. (2012). Economic Growth. Economic Freedom. and the Resource Curse. Journal of Private Enterprise. 28(1). 23–46.
Cebula. (2013). Which Economic Freedoms Influence Per Capita Real Income? Applied Economics Letters. 20(4). 368-372.
Daei Karimzadeh. S. & M. Soleimani. (2017). The Effect of Economic Freedom on The Performance of Banks in Iran. Quarterly Journal of The Macro and Strategic Policies. 19. 77-100. (In Persian).
Dawson. J. W. (2003). Causality in The Freedom–Growth Relationship. European Journal of Political Economy. 19. 479–95.
De Haan. J. & J.-E. Sturm. )2003(. Does More Democracy Lead to Greater Economic Freedom? New Evidence for Developing Countries. European Journal of Political Economy. 19(3).  547–63.
Economou F. (2019). Economic Freedom and Asymmetric Crisis Effects on FDI inflows: The case of four South European economies. Research in International Business and Finance. 49. 114-126.
Emerson. P. M. )2006(. Corruption, Competition and Democracy. Journal of Development Economics. 81(1). 193–212.
Fetros. M. H.; Akbari Shahrestani. F. & M. Mirzaei. (2012). Investigating the Effect of Economic Freedom on Life Expectancy A panel data Analysis of Selected Countries. Including Iran. Journal of Economic Strategy. 193-169. (In Persian).
Graeff. P. & G. Mehlkop. )2003(.The Impact of Economic Freedom on Corruption: Different Patterns for Rich and Poor Countries. European Journal of Political Economy. 19(3). 605–20.
Grubel. H. (2015). Determinants of economic freedom: Theory and empirical evidence. Tech. rep. Vancouver. BC: Fraser Institute.
Gwaltney. J. D. Robert A. Lawson & Randall G. Holcombe. (1999). Economic Freedom and the Environment for Economic Growth. Journal of Institutional and Theoretical Economics. 155(4). 643-663.
Hadri. K. & Y. Rao. (2008). Panel Stationarity Test with Structural Breaks. Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics .70 (2). 245–269.
Haji Yousefi. A. M. (1997). Rent. rentier state and rentierism: a conceptual study. Political-Economic Information. 126. 155-152. (In Persian).
Hashemi. F. (2017). Comparative Study of The Effect of Economic Freedom on The Budget Deficit in Iran. Quarterly Journal of Financial Economics. 41. 176-155. (In Persian).
Heckelman. Jac C. & B. Wilson. (2015). Fractionalization. Rent Seeking. and Economic Freedom. Public Finance Review.
 Hussain M. E. & M. Haque. (2016). Impact of Economic Freedom on the Growth Rate: A Panel Data Analysis. Economies. 4. 5; doi:10.3390.
Islam Md. R. (2018). Wealth Inequality. Democracy and Economic Freedom. Journal of Comparative Economics. 46(4). 920-935.
Ben Jann, 2008. "NLCHECK: Stata module to check linearity assumption after model estimation," Statistical Software Components S456968, Boston College Department of Economics.
Jichi. S. & S. Cabro. (2019). Does Economic Freedom Determine the Control of Corruption? Kapadokya Akademik Bakış. 2(2). 79–96.
Khodaparast Mashhadi. M.; A. Fallahi. Mohammad & A. Ariana. (2014). Investigating the Effect of Social Capital and Economic Freedom on Iran's Economic Growth. Journal of Macroeconomics. 17. 98-75. (In Persian).
Liao. M. (2018). International Evidence on Economic Freedom. Governance. and Firm Performance. International Corporate Governance and Regulation. Advances in Financial Economics. 20. 85-103.
March. R. J. C. Lyford. & B. Powell. (2017). Causes and Barriers to Increases in Economic Freedom. International Review of Economics and Finance. 64(1). 87–103.
Mehlum. H. K. Moene. & R. Torvik (2006). Institutions and the Resource Curse. Economic Journal. 116. 1-20.
Miller. T. A. B. Kim & J. M. Roberts. (2019). Heritage Foundation Economic freedom indices. Available at http://www.heritage.org/Index/Explore.Accessed March 20. 2020.
Moeini Fard. M. & Mehrara. M. (2015). The Impact of Abundant Natural Resources on The Quality of Governance in Developing Countries. Journal of Economic Development Policy. 9. (In Persian).
Mohammadzadeh. Y. & Yahyavi Dizaj. J. (2017). The Impact of Economic Freedom on Attracting Foreign Direct Investment in Selected Countries with a GMM Approach. Journal of Quantitative Economics. 3. 103-73. (In Persian).
Mohammadzadeh. Y.; Hekmati F. S. & K. Mir Ali Ashrafi. (2016). Investigating the Impact of Economic Freedom on Entrepreneurship Development in Selected Countries. Entrepreneurship Development. 376-357. (In Persian).
Motefakker Azad. M. A.; Asadzadeh. A. Amini Khozani. M. & M. Shirkesh. (2013). Analysis of The Simultaneous Effects of Economic Freedom. Human Development and Political Freedom in Selected Islamic Countries (2001-2001). Quarterly Journal of Economic Growth and Development Research.  13. 32-49. (In Persian).
Nakhaei. F. Khoshnoodi. A. & M. Dashtban. (2015). Investigating the Interactive Effect of Economic Freedom and Foreign Direct Investment on Economic Growth Using GMM Approach. Journal of Economic Development Policy. 8. 129-95. (In Persian).
Nordin N. N. & N. H. Nordin. (2017).  The Role of Economic Freedom in Research and Development- Productivity Growth Nexus: Study Based on Different Income Level on Developing Countries.  Journal of Economic Cooperation and Development. 38. 1. 1-28.
Pesaran. M. H. & T. Yamagata. (2007). Testing slope homogeneity in large panels. Econometrics. MDPI. 142 (1).50.
Pourjavan. A.; A. Shahabadi. M. Ghorbannejad & H. Amiri. (2014). The Impact of Abundant Natural Resources on The Governance Performance of Selected Oil and Developed Countries: GMM Panel Approach. Quarterly Journal of Economic Modeling Research.  4. 32-1. (In Persian).
Powell. B. & Matt E. Ryan. (2006). Does Development Aid Lead to Economic Freedom? Journal of Private Enterprise. 22(1). 1–21.
Rahmani. T.; Behpour. S. & R. Shojauddin. (2013). Investigating the Effect of Economic Freedom on The Economic Fluctuations of Selected Developing Countries. Journal of Applied Economic Research. 3.. 131-150. (In Persian).
Razmi. A. A.; M. J. Razmi. & S. Shahraki. (2009). The Impact of Economic Freedom on Economic Growth with the Approach of the Institutionalist School: A Study of Science. Journal of Knowledge and Development. 28.. 127-157. (In Persian).
Rezaei. M.; K. Yavari.  M. Ezzati & M. Etesami. (2015). Investigating the Effect of Abundant Natural Resources (Oil and Gas) On Financial Repression and Economic Growth Through the Channel Affecting Income Distribution. Iran Energy Economics Research.  14. 89-122. (In Persian).
Sachs. D. J. & A.M. Warner (1995). Natural Resource Abundance and Economic Growth. NBER Working Paper Series No. 5398. National Bureau of Economic Research.
Samadi, A. H., & Owjimehr, S. (2021). Does Economic Globalization Have a Similar Effect on Governance for All Countries in the World? Dynamics of Institutional Change in Emerging Market Economies: Theories, Concepts and Mechanisms, 213.
Sameti. M.; Gugerdchian. M. & A. Gugerdchian (2010). Theoretical and Experimental Analysis of the Impact of Economic Freedom on Expenditure Cost: A Case Study of OECD Countries. Journal of Economic Research. 2. 95-113. (In Persian).
Sameti. M.; Shahnazi. R. & Z. Dehghan Shabani. (2006). Investigating the Effect of Economic Freedom on Financial Corruption (Case Study with Panel Data Approach). Iranian Journal of Economic Research.  28. 89-110. (In Persian).
Sattari. O.; Yavari. K. Heidari. H. & M. Etemadi. (2016). Investigating the Effect of Monetary and Financial Freedom on The Transparency of Monetary Policy in Low-Income. Middle-Income and High-Income Countries. Journal of Applied Theories of Economics.  4. 153-176. (In Persian).
Shahabadi. A. & Sadeghi. H. (2014). Natural Resources Abundance and GDP Per Capita in Oil Countries with Emphasis on Economic Freedom. Quarterly Journal of Economic Growth and Development Research. 20. 98-79. (In Persian).
Shahabadi. A. & Ganji. M. (2015). The Impact of Good Governance on The Economic Freedom of Selected Countries in The Mena Region. Journal of Economy and Regional Development. 9. 288-264. (In Persian).
Shahabadi. A. & Moradi. A. (2016). The Interaction of Abundance of Natural Resources and Economic Freedom on Private Sector Investment in Selected Oil Exporting Countries. Economic Research. 4. 831-858. (In Persian).
Shahabadi. A.; Sari Gol. S. & H. Tanhaei. (2015). Governance and Economic Freedom (Case Study of D8 and G7 Group Countries). Quarterly Journal of Macro and Strategic Policies. 12. 123-148. (In Persian).
Shahabadi. A. & Bahari. Z. (2014). The Impact of Political Stability and Economic Freedom on the Economic Growth of Selected Developed and Developing Countries. Quarterly Journal of Economic Growth and Development Research. 16. 53-72. (In Persian).
Shahabadi. A. & Jameh Bozorgi. A. (2014). The Impact of Economic. Political and Civil Freedom on Immigration (with Emphasis on Elite Migration). Journal of Majlis and Rahbord. 77. 41-69. (In Persian).
Sayari. N.  R. Sari.  & Sh. Hammoudeh. (2018). The Impact of Value-Added Components of GDP And FDI On Economic Freedom in Europe. Economic Systems. 42(2).  282-294.
Tao Xu. (2019). Economic Freedom and Bilateral Direct Investment. Economic Modelling. 78.  172-179.
Tortensson. J. (1994). Property Rights and Economic Growth: An Empirical Study. Kyklos. 47. 231–47.
Yamarik S. & Ch. Redmon (2017). Economic Freedom and Corruption: New Cross-Country Panel Data Evidence. Journal of Private Enterprise. 32(2). 17–44.
Yamarik S. & Ch. Redmon (2017). Economic Freedom and Corruption: New Cross-Country Panel Data Evidence. Journal of Private Enterprise. 32(2). 17–44.
CAPTCHA Image